The Church and the “Worship Experience”

Samuel Neudeck
16 November 2011

The landscape of American churches has undergone a significant transformation over the past century, particularly within Evangelical congregations. One major shift is in how worship is perceived and practiced. Unlike a hundred years ago, today’s worship often prioritizes the experience over the content of the sermon or the depth of community relationships. Instead of focusing on Christ-centered teachings, many churches emphasize music and emotional engagement.

The Shift in Worship

To understand this change, we can look back to the 1960s and 70s. During this period, many churches began to reassess their worship practices. Traditionally, worship included various forms of praise and thanksgiving, but it has increasingly been defined primarily by music. When people think of worship today, they often think first of songs and musical styles.

This shift was particularly evident in liturgical churches, where traditional practices were questioned. The cultural upheaval of the 1960s encouraged many to seek new expressions of faith. Some church leaders asked: “Why not adopt lively songs and informal prayers from other evangelical traditions?” This inquiry led to a dramatic reimagining of worship, incorporating new music and more spontaneous forms of expression.

While this evolution in worship can be seen as positive, emphasizing engagement and joy, it has also led to a troubling focus. Music now often becomes the main attraction, drawing large crowds but potentially overshadowing the deeper messages of faith and community.

The Rise of Contemporary Worship

The rise of contemporary Christian music in the 1990s played a pivotal role in this transformation. The blend of rock music with Christian themes resonated with many, particularly the youth. This cultural movement can be traced back to the earlier Jesus Movement, which emerged from the countercultural waves of the 1960s.

As churches embraced this new musical style, they began to shift not just in sound but in their overall approach to worship. Many congregations adopted a more casual atmosphere, reflecting the changing preferences of their communities.

Architectural Changes and Their Impact

The architecture of churches has also changed significantly, reinforcing this new focus on experience. Early Christians often met in homes, and it wasn’t until the time of Constantine that church buildings became commonplace. As Christianity grew, so did the scale and design of these buildings, influenced by the architecture of the day. Grand cathedrals symbolized the authority and tradition of the church, creating a formal and ceremonial atmosphere.

However, from the 1980s onward, the emphasis shifted again. Churches began designing spaces that resembled theaters rather than sanctuaries. Stages replaced traditional pulpits, and the layout often prioritized sightlines to the stage, encouraging a performance-oriented culture. This shift has led to what some describe as an “ADD church,” where the need for engagement and entertainment has become paramount. As one friend aptly put it, “Modern churches try to sell you ‘church,’ and we are buying it.”

Wayne Taylor, a missionary I spoke with, highlighted a change in how congregations interact with one another. In the 1950s, people were comfortable sitting closely together in pews, but today’s churches favor individual chairs. This change not only reflects societal preferences for personal space but also necessitates larger buildings to accommodate the same number of attendees.

Conclusion: Balancing Experience with Core Values

As we look at these changes—both in worship style and church architecture—it’s clear that churches are increasingly focused on creating a comfortable and entertaining environment. While there is nothing inherently wrong with adapting to modern culture, it’s crucial that the core values of Christianity remain central. The church must prioritize biblical teachings, community building, and spiritual growth alongside engaging worship experiences.

Ultimately, the challenge for today’s churches is to strike a balance: to create a welcoming environment that engages people while ensuring that the foundation of worship remains rooted in faith and meaningful connection with God and one another.

---

Works Cited

• Duncan, J. Ligon, et al. Perspectives on Christian Worship: 5 Views. Nashville, Tenn: B & H Academic, 2009.
• Kilde, Jeanne Halgren. When Church Became Theatre: The Transformation of Evangelical Architecture and Worship in Nineteenth-Century America. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002.
• Nimtz, Timon. Personal interview. 11:30 PM November 16, 2011.
• Raschke, Carl A. The Next Reformation: Why Evangelicals Must Embrace Postmodernity. Grand Rapids, Mich: Baker Academic, 2004.
• Taylor, Wayne. Personal interview. 8:20 PM November 15, 2011.